newsletter open
Join our growing list of product knowledge seekers, and get our insights on all things product.
You're now subscribed to our newsletter!
Something went wrong, please try again later.
Back to Articles

When and When Not to Include AI in Digital Products: A Practical Guide

In today’s ever-evolving world of digital products and services, artificial intelligence (AI) stands out as a quantum leap forward, at times. It has the potential to transform user experiences, streamline operations, and offer deep, insightful analyses that were once beyond our reach. But here's the thing: not every digital product needs AI. Sometimes, simpler, tried-and-true solutions work better and more efficiently.

Knowing when to integrate AI into your product and when to keep it simple is crucial for successful product development. This decision can make or break the user experience and the product's overall success. At Power Shifter, we get how important this choice is. That’s why we’ve developed an easy-to-use scorecard to guide product developers and managers in making smart decisions about incorporating AI.

Understanding the Value of AI

AI offers a trove of benefits. It can automate repetitive tasks, personalize user experiences, and provide predictive analytics that inform decision-making. Automation boosts efficiency and productivity, while personalized experiences enhance customer satisfaction. Predictive analytics help businesses anticipate market trends and make informed decisions. On top of that, Generative AI brings an extra layer of innovation. It can create new content, such as text, images, video, and even music, reducing the creative burden and speeding up content production. This technology can also assist in brainstorming sessions, providing fresh ideas and unique solutions that might not have been considered otherwise.

But let's not gloss over the challenges. AI technology can be complex and costly, requiring extensive data for effective training. It demands significant expertise and resources. The implementation and maintenance costs can be steep, and gathering the vast amounts of data needed can be daunting.

Despite these hurdles, our mission remains clear: integrate AI only when it adds clear, tangible value. We don’t just throw AI into the mix for the sake of it. We aim for it to enhance functionality and align seamlessly with our broader business goals, contributing to our growth and success.

The AI Integration Scorecard

To help our clients decide whether to include AI in their digital products, we use a scorecard that evaluates key factors:

Problem Complexity

Evaluate the complexity of the problem:

  • High Complexity (Score: 5): Problems requiring intricate decision-making processes, such as natural language processing or large-scale predictive analytics. Think about diagnosing medical conditions from imaging data—it's complex and needs AI’s advanced capabilities.
  • Medium Complexity (Score: 3): Problems needing some degree of automation or pattern recognition. Automating customer support chatbots falls here. The AI doesn’t diagnose diseases but handles diverse customer queries.
  • Low Complexity (Score: 1): Simple problems solvable by basic algorithms or manual processes, like data entry automation. It’s straightforward and doesn’t need AI’s advanced skills.

Data Availability

Assess the availability and quality of data:

  • Abundant Data (Score: 5): High-quality, structured data readily available, like e-commerce platforms with extensive customer purchase history.
  • Moderate Data (Score: 3): Some data available but requiring significant cleaning or augmentation. A new social media app with initial user data fits here.
  • Limited Data (Score: 1): Scarce or low-quality data, like a startup with minimal user data and no established data collection processes.

User Impact

Determine the impact on user experience:

  • High Impact (Score: 5): AI significantly enhances the user experience or provides critical functionality. AI-powered personalization in streaming services is a prime example.
  • Moderate Impact (Score: 3): AI adds noticeable but non-critical improvements. AI-based email filtering systems fall here—helpful but not essential.
  • Low Impact (Score: 1): AI’s role is minimal, offering marginal improvements, like AI suggestions for filling out forms.

Cost and Resources

Consider the budget and resources available:

  • High Budget and Resources (Score: 5): Ample budget and resources for AI development and maintenance, like a large corporation with a dedicated AI team.
  • Moderate Budget and Resources (Score: 3): Some budget and resources available, requiring strategic allocation. A mid-sized company investing in AI fits here.
  • Low Budget and Resources (Score: 1): Minimal budget and resources, making AI development challenging, like a small startup on a tight budget.

Technical Feasibility

Evaluate the technical environment and expertise:

  • Highly Feasible (Score: 5): Optimal situation for AI integration with a compatible technical environment and skilled team. An established tech company with cloud infrastructure and AI developers fits here.
  • Moderately Feasible (Score: 3): Achievable AI integration requiring some adjustments or additional expertise. A solid tech base needing extra help fits this category.
  • Low Feasibility (Score: 1): Significant technical obstacles and lack of expertise make AI integration difficult, like a traditional company with legacy systems.

Scalability and Future Growth

Assess scalability and potential for future growth:

  • High Scalability (Score: 5): AI solution can scale effectively with business growth, like cloud-based AI solutions.
  • Moderate Scalability (Score: 3): Capable of scaling but with limitations, like an AI system needing periodic updates.
  • Low Scalability (Score: 1): Limited scalability, like a locally hosted AI model that can’t easily expand.

By using this AI integration scorecard, Power Shifter ensures that AI is included in digital products only when it adds significant value and aligns with the client’s goals. This approach helps avoid unnecessary complexity and ensures that resources are allocated efficiently, leading to successful and impactful digital products.

We understand that this scorecard is a high-level guide designed to get you thinking about the potential uses of AI. It’s not meant to be overly detailed but rather a starting point to spark conversations and considerations. At Power Shifter, we know that every project is unique and requires a tailored approach. We’re here to dive deeper and provide the detailed expertise needed to make the right decisions for your specific needs.

If you're considering integrating AI into your digital products, contact Power Shifter. Our expertise in AI and digital transformation can help you make informed decisions and build products that truly enhance your business.

We leverage various AI tools to assist with transcription, grammar, consistency, and other corrections in our writing. GenAI is not used to generate net-new content in our article writing. These tools help ensure clarity and accuracy, enabling us to share our insights effectively.

Link copied to clipboard